How to Choose an Indoor Trainer - Part 2

Screen Shot 2016-11-19 at 3.48.12 PM.png

In the last post, we introduced most of different types of trainers found on the market today. In this post, we will be looking at different types of Smart Trainers. In a smart trainer the resistance unit has built-in electronics that transmit your speed (and so much more) to an ANT+ or Bluetooth capable device. From there, the information is transmitted to your device, where you can tap into various training apps, or to Zwift, a turbo trainer game that enables you to ride with other cyclists in a virtual environment.

 

Budget Smart Trainer (sub-$500) Budget: these tend to be basic in functions, and lack automated controls, but some do still have some electronics.  Most apps support these in a basic manner.

A great low budget Smart Trainer (apprx. $400) that gets excellent reviews is the Tacx Satori Smart (Click on the link to get all the specs). This is one of the trainers currently featured in our store.

PRO:

·      It self-generates ANT+ and Bluetooth Smart signals so doesn’t need a main hook-up

·      effortlessly syncs power, speed and cadence data to iOS, Android and Windows PCs.

·      The free training software is intuitive and it’s compatible with Zwift or other online simulators.

·      it comes with a front wheel-levelling block.

·      Ride feel is smooth and balanced

·      there’s a mechanical remote lever to add resistance.

CON:

·      Like most budget trainers, the metal-sheathed roller can slip under sprint loads until you get the tension right

·      It’s noisy at high speeds

·      No Slope variance

 

Mid-Range Budget Trainer ($500-$1000): Mid-Range $400-$1,000: These are where we see electronic resistance control, as well as the majority of features and full app integration.

The CycleOps Magnus (approx. $800) has proven to be a solid trainer at this price point (click on link to get all the specs). This trainer can be special ordered with 2 day delivery to our store.

PROS

·       Light and quiet: Noise level at 20 mph is a quiet 69-70 decibels

·       The trainer is equipped with dual ANT+ FE-C and Bluetooth 4.0 technologies, allowing any cyclist to connect to their favourite virtual training software program, such as CycleOps Virtual Training, Zwift or Trainer Road.

·       comes with CycleOps patented clutch knob that gives you the perfect roller to tire tension during each ride = consistent virtual power.

·       It also simulates up to a 15% incline

·       It doesn’t have direct-drive, which allows you to remove your back tyre completely and fix your bike directly to the trainer.

·       the CycleOps Magnus requires you to connect to power to operate as a smart trainer. If you don’t connect it to power, it will operate as a regular fluid trainer.

 

High-End Trainers ($1000 +): High-End $1,000+: These are the high-end trainers, and primarily distinguish themselves from the mid-range by increasing durability and reducing noise.

The CycleOps Hammer Direct Drive Smart Trainer (approx. $1620) is really one of the very best on the market. If you are looking for the ultimate indoor cycling experience, this is the trainer for you.

Pros:

·       direct drive system (allows you to remove your back tyre completely and fix your bike directly to the trainer.)

·       incomparable bike compatibility and device connectivity (by far the best on the market)

·       ability to replicate real world inertia

·       the Hammer isn’t silent, but it’s also not loud

·       fast responding electromagnetic resistance

·       the sensation of rolling on smooth asphalt

·       simulate grades up to 20%

·       lightweight (46lbs) and foldable for easy storage

·       front wheel block

·       connects to Zwift, TrainerRoad and all your favourite apps,

CONs:

·       You must provide and install a cassette. the Hammer supports Shimano 8/9/10/11 speed cassettes.

·       you’ll need to make sure you have the right tools to install a cassette

·       required to be plugged in, unlike the Tacx Neo ($1800) that can be used wirelessly. (See below for a short description)

That was a brief look at the different types of Smart Trainers on the market right now. That said, there are tons more out there. According to my research, these 3-4 stand-out in their price range. Others worth mentioning are the Tacx Vortex Smart and Tacx Bushido. (Mid range $$). Learn more about these Tacx Interactive Trainers here.  In the next post, we'll be looking at some of the best cycling apps and the virtual cycling experience. **(All the trainers mentioned in this article can be special ordered and delivered to our store in 2 business days) 

 

Another Excellent High-End Trainer that needs mentioning is the TACX NEO SMART. 

  • Real direct drive trainer with a powerful motor placed directly onto the cassette, eliminating additional gearing
  • Low revolutions, reducing noise to a minimum
  • Foldable and compact frame design
  • Can be used completely wireless or hooked to a power outlet
  • Bluetooth and ANT+ FE-C capable
  • Measure speed, cadence and power
  • Maximum resistance 2200 Watts
  • Realistic climbing up to 25% and downhill to -5%
  • Simulate real road pattern such as cobblestone, ice and concrete plates

Julie Brunelle

Heritage Bikes and Rentals , Gore Street East, Perth, ON,

Co-owner of new startup, Heritage Bikes and rentals. Offering Guided and unguided Tours of Perth ON and Lanark county.